Welcome to AppSec Unlocked. In our previous episodes, we explored building Security Champions programs and effective developer training. Today, we're tackling a challenge that keeps many CISOs up at night: How do you actually measure if your security awareness programs are working?
Because let's face it – if you can't measure it, you can't improve it. But more importantly, if you can't prove its value, you can't justify its budget.
THE METRICS TRAP
Let's start with what everyone gets wrong. I recently spoke with a Security Director who proudly announced that 100% of their employees completed security training. Great news, right?
But when I asked about their phishing click rates? Still high. Their security incidents? No significant reduction. Their developer security practices? Largely unchanged.
This illustrates the first major problem in security awareness metrics: measuring activity instead of impact. Completion rates tell you nothing about effectiveness.
The real question isn't "Did they take the training?" It's "Did the training change anything?"
MEANINGFUL METRICS FRAMEWORK
Let's break down security awareness metrics into three categories:
Leading Indicators
Security tool adoption rates
Proactive security consultations
Security requirements in project planning
Current State Indicators
Security bug detection rates
Security review participation
Security design patterns usage
Lagging Indicators
Security incident rates
Time to detect/respond to threats
Cost per security incident
But here's the key: You need all three types to tell the complete story.
BEHAVIORAL METRICS
Let's get specific about measuring behavioral change:
First: Baseline Metrics
Initial security assessment scores
Current incident response times
Existing security practice adoption
Second: Engagement Metrics
Quality of security discussions
Voluntary security tool usage
Security Champions program participation
Third: Impact Metrics
Changes in security incident patterns
Improvement in code security scores
Speed of security vulnerability remediation
ROI CALCULATIONS
Now for the part your executives care about most: Return on Investment.
Here's a practical framework:
Direct Cost Savings:
Reduced security incidents
Faster vulnerability remediation
Lower third-party audit findings
Indirect Benefits:
Improved developer productivity
Faster release cycles
Enhanced customer trust
Risk Reduction:
Decreased threat surface
Improved threat detection
Better incident response
The key is translating these metrics into business impact. Don't just report numbers – tell the story they represent.
GETTING STARTED
Let's talk about how to implement this in your organization:
Start Small:
Pick 3-5 key metrics
Establish clear baselines
Set realistic improvement targets
Use Automation:
Security tools integration
Automated metric collection
Real-time dashboards
Regular Reviews:
Monthly trend analysis
Quarterly program adjustments
Annual strategic planning
WRAP-UP
Remember these key points:
Focus on impact over activity
Measure behavioral change
Connect metrics to business outcomes
Use data to drive improvement
Tell the story behind the numbers
Next episode, we'll explore how to build security culture by design. But for now, I'd love to hear about your experiences with security metrics. What measurements have you found most valuable?
This is AppSec Unlocked, thanks for listening.
Share this post